Implement Token Verification

Oct 13, 2025 by pinkandtrash.com 43 views

OAuth2 is Insecure: A Critical Examination of the Authentication Protocol

Introduction

OAuth2 is a widely used authentication protocol that enables secure authorization between applications and services. However, despite its popularity, OAuth2 has a significant security flaw that can be exploited by malicious actors. In this article, we will delve into the issue of insecure OAuth2 tokens and explore a potential solution to mitigate this vulnerability.

The Problem with OAuth2 Tokens

OAuth2 tokens are typically represented as JSON Web Tokens (JWTs), which are digitally signed and contain a payload of user information. However, the current implementation of OAuth2 tokens in Formbar OAuth2 is insecure, as there is no way for applications to verify that the JWT tokens are created by Formbar. This means that anyone can create JWT tokens with their own data and create new accounts or even sign into other people's accounts on applications using the OAuth2 system.

This vulnerability is particularly concerning for applications that have features that require teacher permissions, as anyone can spoof their permissions. For instance, a malicious actor could create a JWT token with a teacher's permissions and gain unauthorized access to sensitive information or features.

The Example of the Issue

To illustrate the problem, consider the following example:

https://github.com/user-attachments/assets/f3412153-3b8a-4fcc-973d-2bd1b9da20d9

In this example, a malicious actor can create a JWT token with their own data and create a new account or sign into an existing account on an application using the OAuth2 system. This can have serious consequences, including unauthorized access to sensitive information or features.

A Potential Solution: Private and Public Keys

To mitigate the vulnerability of insecure OAuth2 tokens, we propose a solution that involves the use of private and public keys. The private key would be used for signing the OAuth2 token, while the public key would be used to verify that the token was genuinely created by Formbar.

Here's how it would work:

Private Key: The private key would be stored securely on the backend, and would be used to sign the OAuth2 token. This ensures that only the backend can create valid OAuth2 tokens.
Public Key: The public key would be provided to the application, and would be used to verify the authenticity of the OAuth2 token. This ensures that the application can trust the token and use it to authenticate the user.
Token Verification: When the application receives an OAuth2 token, it would use the public key to verify the token's signature. If the signature is valid, the application can trust the token and use it to authenticate the user.

Benefits of the Solution

The proposed solution has several benefits, including:

Improved Security: By using private and public keys, we can ensure that only the backend can create valid OAuth2 tokens, and that the application can trust the token and use it to authenticate the user.
Reduced Risk of Spoofing: By verifying the token's signature, we can reduce the risk of spoofing and unauthorized access to sensitive information or features.
Increased Trust: By using a secure token verification process, we can increase trust between the application and the user, and ensure that the user's information is protected.

Conclusion

In conclusion, OAuth2 is insecure due to the lack of verification of JWT tokens. However, by using private and public keys, we can mitigate this vulnerability and ensure that only the backend can create valid OAuth2 tokens. This solution has several benefits, including improved security, reduced risk of spoofing, and increased trust between the application and the user. We hope that this article has raised awareness about the issue of insecure OAuth2 tokens and has provided a potential solution to mitigate this vulnerability.

Recommendations

Based on our analysis, we recommend that developers and organizations using OAuth2 tokens take the following steps:

Implement Token Verification: Implement a token verification process that uses private and public keys to verify the authenticity of the OAuth2 token.
Use Secure Storage: Store the private key securely on the backend, and ensure that it is not accessible to unauthorized parties.
Provide Public Key: Provide the public key to the application, and ensure that it is used to verify the token's signature.
Monitor and Update: Regularly monitor the OAuth2 token system and update the implementation to ensure that it remains secure and compliant with best practices.

By following these recommendations, we can ensure that OAuth2 tokens are secure and trustworthy, and that users' information is protected.
OAuth2 is Insecure: A Critical Examination of the Authentication Protocol

Q&A: OAuth2 Security Concerns

In our previous article, we discussed the security concerns surrounding OAuth2 tokens and proposed a solution using private and public keys. In this article, we will address some of the frequently asked questions (FAQs) related to OAuth2 security concerns.

Q: What is the main security concern with OAuth2 tokens?

A: The main security concern with OAuth2 tokens is that anyone can create JWT tokens with their own data and create new accounts or even sign into other people's accounts on applications using the OAuth2 system.

Q: Why is it a problem that anyone can create JWT tokens?

A: It's a problem because it allows malicious actors to gain unauthorized access to sensitive information or features. For instance, a malicious actor could create a JWT token with a teacher's permissions and gain access to sensitive information or features.

Q: How can I protect my application from this vulnerability?

A: To protect your application from this vulnerability, you can implement a token verification process that uses private and public keys to verify the authenticity of the OAuth2 token. This ensures that only the backend can create valid OAuth2 tokens, and that the application can trust the token and use it to authenticate the user.

Q: What is the difference between a private key and a public key?

A: A private key is used for signing the OAuth2 token, while a public key is used to verify the token's signature. The private key is stored securely on the backend, and the public key is provided to the application.

Q: Why do I need to use a private key and a public key?

A: You need to use a private key and a public key to ensure that only the backend can create valid OAuth2 tokens, and that the application can trust the token and use it to authenticate the user. This provides an additional layer of security and ensures that the token is genuine.

Q: How do I implement token verification using private and public keys?

A: To implement token verification using private and public keys, you need to:

Generate a private key: Generate a private key on the backend and store it securely.
Generate a public key: Generate a public key from the private key and provide it to the application.
Sign the token: Use the private key to sign the OAuth2 token.
Verify the token: Use the public key to verify the token's signature.

Q: What are the benefits of using private and public keys for token verification?

A: The benefits of using private and public keys for token verification include:

Improved security: By using private and public keys, you can ensure that only the backend can create valid OAuth2 tokens, and that the application can trust the token and use it to authenticate the user.
Reduced risk of spoofing: By verifying the token's signature, you can reduce the risk of spoofing and unauthorized access to sensitive information or features.
Increased trust: By using a secure token verification process, you can increase trust between the application and the user, and ensure that the user's information is protected.

Q: What are some best practices for implementing OAuth2 security?

A: Some best practices for implementing OAuth2 security include:

Use secure storage: Store the private key securely on the backend, and ensure that it is not accessible to unauthorized parties.
Provide public key: Provide the public key to the application, and ensure that it is used to verify the token's signature.
Monitor and update: Regularly monitor the OAuth2 token system and update the implementation to ensure that it remains secure and compliant with best practices.

Q: What are some common mistakes to avoid when implementing OAuth2 security?

A: Some common mistakes to avoid when implementing OAuth2 security include:

Not using secure storage: Not storing the private key securely on the backend, and making it accessible to unauthorized parties.
Not providing public key: Not providing the public key to the application, or not using it to verify the token's signature.
Not monitoring and updating: Not regularly monitoring the OAuth2 token system and updating the implementation to ensure that it remains secure and compliant with best practices.

By following these best practices and avoiding common mistakes, you can ensure that your OAuth2 implementation is secure and trustworthy, and that users' information is protected.